After researching and asking questions....the winner is The Local Dump! (aka: Convenience Center)
It is only $65 per Year and even covers yard waste to the local landfill for half truck load once per week. My husband was excited about that because even paying $76 per quarter...we still had to pay to take our own yard waste to the landfill at $5.00 per trip. This adds up in the summer months when mowing is at least once per week.
Oh yeah...on the Green Side, they also recycle almost everything at no addtional charge..super awesome...so $65 per year is exactly what it means!
We will have to purchase a new trash can $30 from Lowe's Home Improvement and Large Trash Bags ($27 and will be enough for the whole year). The trash can is of course a "one time purchase." The savings more than makes up for the purchases above and will pay for themselves in the first three months of savings! Yay!